Value for Tuesday of Week 22 in the season of Growth

Beliefs and Convictions

A conviction is a strong belief, reaching more fully beyond thinking into emotion. Of course, beliefs too are influenced by emotion. Mainly, though, both are in the domain of thinking.

  • We have always held to the hope, the belief, the conviction that there is a better life, a better world, beyond the horizon. [Franklin D. Roosevelt]
  • It’s the repetition of affirmations that leads to belief. And once that belief becomes a deep conviction, things begin to happen. [Muhammad Ali]
  • Democracy is a pathetic belief in the collective wisdom of individual ignorance. [attributed to H. L. Mencken]

 
Gustave Dore, The Second Crusaders Encounter the Remains of the First Crusaders (1877)People have believed things with utter conviction – a combination of thought and action – and been consummately wrong. A conviction brings a creative power that is not present in a mere belief. But if the conviction is not in harmony with reality or with desirable ends, the result can be destructive instead of creative.

Real

True Narratives

Two perspectives on Istanbul’s history: “ . . . it’s a virtue of both books that they’re able to depict this transformation subtly while at the same time showing how intricate and improbable Istanbul’s history has been. The effect is rather like stumbling across the Serpent Column late at night after carousing in Istanbul’s 21st-century nightclubs: a melancholic sense of historical vertigo.

Essay collections, illustrating the power, pros and cons of belief:

Technical and Analytical Readings

Photographs

Documentary and Educational Films

Imaginary

Fictional Narratives

In Les Misérables, Javert’s rigid opinions shape his personality and character.

This man was composed of two very simple and two very good sentiments, comparatively; but he rendered them almost bad, by dint of exaggerating them,--respect for authority, hatred of rebellion; and in his eyes, murder, robbery, all crimes, are only forms of rebellion. He enveloped in a blind and profound faith every one who had a function in the state, from the prime minister to the rural policeman. He covered with scorn, aversion, and disgust every one who had once crossed the legal threshold of evil. He was absolute, and admitted no exceptions. On the one hand, he said, "The functionary can make no mistake; the magistrate is never the wrong." On the other hand, he said, "These men are irremediably lost. Nothing good can come from them." He fully shared the opinion of those extreme minds which attribute to human law I know not what power of making, or, if the reader will have it so, of authenticating, demons, and who place a Styx at the base of society. He was stoical, serious, austere; a melancholy dreamer, humble and haughty, like fanatics. His glance was like a gimlet, cold and piercing. His whole life hung on these two words: watchfulness and supervision. He had introduced a straight line into what is the most crooked thing in the world; he possessed the conscience of his usefulness, the religion of his functions, and he was a spy as other men are priests. Woe to the man who fell into his hands! He would have arrested his own father, if the latter had escaped from the galleys, and would have denounced his mother, if she had broken her ban. And he would have done it with that sort of inward satisfaction which is conferred by virtue. And, withal, a life of privation, isolation, abnegation, chastity, with never a diversion. It was implacable duty; the police understood, as the Spartans understood Sparta, a pitiless lying in wait, a ferocious honesty, a marble informer, Brutus in Vidocq. [Victor Hugo, Les Misérables (1862), Volume I – Fantine; Book Fifth – The Descent Begins, Chapter V, “Vague Flashes on the Horizon”.]

In this passage, Hugo discusses the revolutionary spirit in France at the time:

Other groups of minds were more serious. In that direction, they sounded principles, they attached themselves to the right. They grew enthusiastic for the absolute, they caught glimpses of infinite realizations; the absolute, by its very rigidity, urges spirits towards the sky and causes them to float in illimitable space. There is nothing like dogma for bringing forth dreams. And there is nothing like dreams for engendering the future. Utopia to-day, flesh and blood to-morrow. [Victor Hugo, Les Misérables (1862), Volume III – Marius; Book Fourth – The Friends of the A B C, Chapter I, “A Group Which Barely Missed Becoming Heroic”.]

Novels:

Poetry

BELIEFS:

CONVICTIONS:

Music: Composers, artists, and major works

Sergiu Celibidache was a conductor known for expressing his beliefs and convictions through his art. “Although he wrote his thesis on the music of Josquin des Pres, more deeply critical to his lasting convictions were his studies in Oriental philosophy. (In the late '80s, when he tells a group of instrumentalists that each one of them is like a drop of water, separate and unique but all constituted of the same liquid which longs to return to the ocean, the maestro evokes metaphors he learned from the Upanishads.) Hindu metaphysics and the Zen Buddhist's embrace of the void seem to inform many of Celibidache's readily professed axioms on music and life.” He was a Zen Buddhist, and “a mystic who had no interest in tradition or the musical mainstream. Intending his music as a continuous flow, he omits all the standard repeats.” Of no surprise, he was not to everyone’s liking; and he was not always duly respectful of others. His recordings “make sense not only on their own musical terms, but as living examples of the philosophical convictions which shaped Celi’s art and blocked a conventional career.” He was the main subject of this documentary film. Here he is in rehearsal in 1965, in rehearsal in 1983, in performance in 1971, in interview, and in a brief clip expressing an opinion. Here is a link to his playlists. 

Like most string quartets, Vagn Holmboe’s (list of recorded performances) sound like extended conversations. Typical of most twentieth-century music, these works are loaded with ambiguity and uncertainty. “The string quartet is a superficially severe and ascetic medium if marginally less so than the string trio or sonata for solo violin. Even so Holmboe’s twenty quartets are masterly examples, modelled on Haydn, carrying a Bartok inflection and irradiated with a sense of the natural world.” Yet each movement begins with an identifiable theme, making these suitable musical expressions of the double-edged swords we call belief and conviction.

  • String Quartet No. 1, M 159, Op. 46 (1949) (approx. 20-27’)
  • String Quartet No. 2, M 161, Op. 47 (1949) (approx. 26-27’)
  • String Quartet No. 3, M 165, Op. 48 (1950) (approx. 22-23’)
  • String Quartet No. 4, M 183, Op. 63 (1954) (approx. 25’) (list of recorded performances)
  • String Quartet No. 5, M 188, Op. 55 (1955) (approx. 20’)
  • String Quartet No. 6, M 210, Op. 78 (1961) (approx. 19’)
  • String Quartet No. 7, M 224, Op. 224 (1965) (approx. 21’)
  • String Quartet No. 8, M 225, Op. 87 (1965) (approx. 19’)
  • String Quartet No. 9, M. 228, Op. 92 (1966, rev. 1969) (approx. 25’)
  • String Quartet No. 10, M 243, Op. 102 (1969) (approx. 26’)
  • String Quartet No. 11, "Quartetto Rustico," M 262, Op. 111 (1972) (approx. 19’)
  • String Quartet No. 12, M 269, Op. 116 (1973) (approx. 22’)
  • String Quartet No. 13, M 277, Op. 124 (1975) (approx. 24’)
  • String Quartet No. 14, M 278, Op. 125 (1975) (approx. 20’)
  • String Quartet No. 15, M 291, Op. 135 (1978) (approx. 17’)
  • String Quartet No. 16, M 305, Op. 146 (1981) (approx. 16’)
  • String Quartet No. 17, M 312, Op. 152, "Mattinata" (Morning) (1983) (approx. 27’)
  • String Quartet No. 18, M 314, Op. 153, "Giornata" (Day) (1982) (approx. 22’)
  • String Quartet No. 19, M 313, Op. 156, "Serata" (1985) (approx. 23’)
  • String Quartet No. 20, M 322, Op. 160, "Notturno" (Night) (1985) (approx. 20’)
  • String Quartet No. 21, Op. Posth. 197, “Quartetto Sereno”

In William Bolcom’s works for violin and piano (including the works for violin alone), the players sound as though they are in constant disagreement about a theme, yet the works congeal into fine and interesting music.

Other compositions:

Albums:

Music: songs and other short pieces

Beliefs:

Convictions:

Visual Arts

Film and Stage

Beliefs:

  • Winter Light, about a Christian pastor’s strugglewith his beliefs
  • The Witch: In seventeenth-century Puritan New England, belief in witches shaped interpretations and actions of events.

Convictions:

latest from

The Work on the Meditations