This Is Our Story

This is Our Story

Humanity United in Action,
Driven By Love and Compassion,
Informed by Science and Reason.

MENUMENU
  • Home
  • Read This First
  • About
  • Cycle-of-Life Season
    • 1 Dormancy
      • Week 01: Human Worth
      • Week 02: Universality
      • Week 03: Justice
      • Week 04: Suffering
      • Week 05: Humility
      • Week 06: Avoiding Harm, or Evil
      • Week 07: Engaging the World
      • Week 08: Order
    • 2 Sowing
      • Week 09: Preferences (Desire)
      • Week 10: Autonomy
      • Week 11: Life as a Journey
      • Week 12: Renewal
      • Week 13: Hope and Optimism
      • Week 14: Self-esteem (Self-worth begins)
      • Week 15: Self-confidence
      • Week 16: Independence (Self-competence)
    • 3 Growth
      • Week 17: Our Future
      • Week 18: Honesty
      • Week 19: Obligation in the World
      • Week 20: Duty toward Others
      • Week 21: Awakening
      • Week 22: Obstacles and Opportunities
      • Week 23: Individuality and Community
    • 4 Ripening
      • Week 24: Honoring
      • Week 25: Excellence
      • Week 26: An Ethic of Generous Service
      • Week 27: Openness
      • Week 28: Transcendence
      • Week 29: Wisdom
      • Week 30: Caring
      • Week 31: Courage
      • Week 32: Citizenship
    • 5 Interlude
      • Week 33: Grounding and Well-Roundedness
      • Week 34: Assertiveness
      • Week 35: Restoration
    • 6 Fulfillment
      • Week 36: Creativity
      • Week 37: Truth
      • Week 38: Love
      • Week 39: Faith
      • Week 40: Rebirth
    • 7 Assessing
      • Week 41: Home and the Past
      • Week 42: Vitality
      • Week 43: Self-actualization and Integrity
      • Week 44: Connectedness
      • Week 45: Empowerment
      • Week 46: Equality
    • 8 Harvest and Celebration
      • Week 47: Flourishing
      • Week 48: Focus and Perspective
      • Week 49: Change
      • Week 50: Finding Our Niche
      • Week 51: Accepting / Surrendering
      • Week 52: Living Religiously
      • Week 53: Celebration and Remembrance
  • Weekdays
    • Sunday
    • Monday
    • Tuesday
    • Wednesday
    • Thursday
    • Friday
    • Saturday
You are here: Home / Cycle-of-Life Season / 3 Growth / Being Scrupulous, Yet Flexible

Being Scrupulous, Yet Flexible

Nelson Mandela in 2008
  • There is no easy walk to freedom anywhere and many of us will have to pass through the valley of the shadow of death again and again before we reach the mountain tops of our desires. [Jawaharlal Nehru, The Unity of India: Collected Writings 1937-1940; later quoted by Nelson Mandela.]
  • . . .  politics as the art of the possible. [Otto von Bismarck]

Nelson Mandela in 1937

Which is better: steadfast scrupulousness or flexible compromise? The question defies a definitive answer. Without Nelson Mandela’s unwillingness to yield to the injustice he experienced, over decades in prison, South African apartheid might not have been dismantled when it was. On the other hand, Barack Obama presided over the passage of national health care legislation in the United States, producing legislation that was less ambitious than could have been achieved a generation earlier through compromise.

Choosing between steadfastness and flexibility requires wisdom, the ability to read people and situations, and a solid set of values. These two virtues, which are also shortcomings in some situations, must be considered together.

Real

True Narratives

The political battle over slavery in the United States is often cited as an example of principle versus compromise.

  • Fergus M. Bordewich, America’s Great Debate: Henry Clay, Stephen A. Douglas, and the Compromise That Preserved the Union (Simon & Schuster, 2012): “The final resolution of the twin problems of slavery and nationhood would not come until it was written in blood.”
  • Allen C. Guelzo, Fateful Lightning: A New History of the Civil War and Reconstruction (Oxford University Press, 2012): “With standoffs looming on several fronts, we cannot know at present whether meaningful compromise can be reached, and whether reason or passion will win the day.”

Most of the works by and about Nelson Mandela illustrate steadfastness but the book by John Carlin shows how Mandela became a crafty political leader who understood and practiced the value of compromise.

  • Nelson Mandela, No Easy Walk to Freedom (1973).
  • Barry Denenberg, Nelson Mandela: No Easy Walk to Freedom (Turtleback, 1991).
  • Nelson Mandela, Long Walk to Freedom: The Autobiography of Nelson Mandela (Little, Brown and Company, 1994).
  • Tom Lodge, Mandela: A Critical Life (Oxford University Press, 2006).
  • Nelson Mandela, An Illustrated Autobiography (Little, Brown and Company, 1996).
  • Anthony Sampson, Mandela: The Authorized Autobiography (Knopf, 1999).
  • Nelson Mandela, Conversations With Myself (Farrar, Straus & Giroux, 2010).
  • David James Smith, Young Mandela: The Revolutionary Years (Little, Brown and Company, 2010).
  • John Carlin, Playing the Enemy: Nelson Mandela and the Game That Made a Nation (Penguin Press, HC, 2008).
  • Sean Wilentz, The Politicians and the Egalitarians: The Hidden History of American Politics (W.W. Norton & Company, 2016). “His thesis is easily stated: Politicians serve the country best when the learn the art of compromise through party-building and not when they stand, prophet-like, outside the fray delivering secular, and sometimes overtly religious, sermons.”
  • John Avlon, Lincoln and the Fight for Peace (Simon &. Schuster, 2022): “In this elegant, almost conversational, exposition of Lincoln the ‘soulful centrist,’ the 16th president appears as the reconciler in chief, who not only saved democracy from destruction in war but also pointed the way to saving it from inertia and futility in peace.”
Nelson Mandela

Imaginary

Visual Arts

  • Umberto Boccioni, Elasticity (1912)

Film and Stage

  • Sergeant York, the biographical drama about Alvin York, a conscientious objector who became the army’s most decorated soldier in World War I: some people may think pacifist and skilled killer to be incompatible ideals but apparently York saw a deeper principle in defense of country.
  • The Man Who Shot Liberty Valence: a Western in which a political figure philosophizes on the compromises necessary to bring order to the Old West

Music: Composers, artists, and major works

Along with others, swing-era jazz trumpeter Buck Clayton earned the title “mainstreamer” by straddling the line between swing revival and modernism. He in particular struck this balance creatively and intelligently.

  • “How Hi the Fi” album (1954)
  • “Basel 1961” album
  • “One for Buck” album (1961)
  • “Jumpin’ at the Woodside” album
  • “Copenhagen Concerts” album
  • compilation of tracks
  • The Huckle-Buck
  • Robbins’ Nest
  • All the Cats Join In
  • Outer Drive
  • All of Me

Compositions:

  • R. Strauss, Ariadne auf Naxos: on the fine art and vagaries of compromise (performances conducted by Kempe, Böhm and Karajan)
  • Dinos Constantinides, String Quartet No. 2, LRC 62, “Mutability”

“Mix a dose of klezmer with a pinch of jazz, add a shot of Balkan and a smidgen of Gypsy, et voilà, you’ve got the recipe for Amsterdam Klezmer Band.” The group adheres to Klezmer tradition, while bringing in other influences. Their albums include:

  • “Fortuna” (2020)
  • “Szikra” (2018)
  • “Benja” (2015)
  • “Blitzmash” (2014)
  • “Mokum” (2014)
  • “Katla” (2011)
  • “Zaraza” (2008)
  • “Son” (2005)
  • “Man Bites Dog Eats Amsterdam Klezmer Band” (2004)
  • “Katakofi” (2003)
  • “Limonchiki” (2001)

Albums:

  • Samuel Leipold, “Viscosity” (how thick is your compromising fluid?)
  • Raphaël Pannier, “Faune”: a jazz musician with a distinct point of view, adaptable in several genres.
  • Matthew Shipp Trio, “Elastic Aspects”

August 23, 2010

Previous Post: « Pushing Through Your Resistance
Next Post: Meeting Obligations in the World »
  • Email
  • Twitter

Topics

Acknowledging Anticipation Appreciation Belonging Choosing Confidence Focus Honoring uniqueness Judgment Motivation Planning Prudence Remembrance Restraining Retreat Reverie Self-knowledge Tenacity Transcending ego Week 01: Human Worth

Web Developers Studio
© 2023 ThisIsOurStory
About | FAQ